Data Table

Table of Net Asset Values of Canadian Energy, Service, Pipeline and Utility Companies





NAV of Energy Companies derived from Corporate Reserve Reports, NAV of Others from Discounted Cash Flow Analysis

April 22,2024

ProducersService and Pipelinesempty
Company NameStock Chart (opens in new tab)Upside to Fair ValueDebt/ CashflowBOE Production Growth/Share (%)Momentum% Natural GasMarket Capitalization ($Million)Upside to ProvedUpside to 2PPdp Value $/shareOther Value $/shareProved(1P) Value $/share2P Value $/share
Advantage EnergyAAV54.71.029.13389173922785.600.3912.9818.94
Arc ResourcesARX-3.50.510.0136314869-27119.860.0218.1827.73
Athabasca OilATH36.1-0.4-5.93228892563.32-0.015.117.84
BaytexBTE-13.01.524.536174117-4761.180.022.665.30
Africa OilAOI23.4-0.7-7.74201107-3391.590.292.323.33
Birchcliff EnergyBIR190.21.3-1.6478115331552246.990.0214.6218.62
Bonterra EnergyBNE261.70.913.526412301983118.820.1418.4425.40
Cardinal EnergyCJ24.10.41.5271210946336.640.017.339.22
CenovusCVE11.30.64.8141853592-1269.234.0328.4336.06
Kiwetinohk EnergyKEC242.00.714.8385255714530611.265.4231.2051.72
Canadian Natural ResourcesCNQ8.20.810.81026113214-41867.430.72101.39124.58
Crescent PointCPG11.61.56.69267433-20323.470.169.6215.86
Crew EnergyCR176.60.4-5.34372695842294.260.218.1714.60
Frontera EnergyFEC184.91.2-4.74126881592263.925.0120.9226.35
OvintivOVV-56.51.66.1124519364-66-485.441.7723.9736.71
EnerplusERF-19.20.29.75355699-38-811.190.0217.0625.14
Freehold RoyaltyFRU-43.30.41.432372156-59-354.690.225.879.24
Gear EnergyGXE108.00.32.33114173511380.710.001.001.57
Gran TierraGTE263.32.48.4703651263457.470.0025.5850.43
Headwater ExplorationHWX-46.4-0.333.82071830-58-402.560.053.234.63
Hemisphere EnergyHME78.4-0.116.94116853942.000.012.583.28
International PetroleumIPCO65.86-0.155.768.0035.082210.9336.4089.2410.640.4923.7532.95
Imperial OilIMO-3.660.4017.4811.000.0051118.85-8.567.4826.8455.7287.23102.53
Prairie ProvidentPPR276.58520.82-83.9350.0036.0150.09132.92374.87-0.020.000.160.33
Journey EnergyJOY175.761.5111.2144.0045.12218.13117.24212.904.721.017.7211.12
Kelt ExplorationKEL153.680.0511.7648.0062.111178.6790.31197.664.390.0111.5318.04
Logan EnergyLGN-31.92-0.9716.3030.0064.58428.26-53.96-19.000.200.010.420.75
Meg EnergyMEG30.640.579.4515.000.008574.3211.9347.3515.950.3434.9446.00
Razor EnergyRZE3161.782.90-36.7853.0019.944.942819.843622.171.011.144.095.21
Nuvista EnergyNVA46.030.2327.9334.0060.232563.6619.7965.767.460.0214.7920.47
Paramount ResourcesPOU46.620.092.3625.0053.644210.6410.4471.1213.844.7832.2549.97
ParexPXT12.140.0214.4846.001.522469.96-7.0522.6718.190.0021.9929.02
Obsidian EnergyOBE113.280.837.3518.0035.45863.5576.59135.0714.920.0619.6526.16
PetrusPRQ152.550.814.0337.0070.18159.72102.10188.381.320.052.613.72
PeytoPEY105.781.483.3516.0086.522897.4265.98135.2311.840.7424.8335.19
Pine Cliff EnergyPNE-19.291.361.4851.0085.84352.41-48.45-4.710.370.000.510.94
Prairiesky RoyaltyPSK-76.510.561.4121.0039.316627.47-78.42-74.764.191.375.997.00
Strathcona ResourcesSCR89.752.1524.132.0022.787138.3145.00125.0310.740.0948.3174.98
Saturn Oil and GasSOIL293.201.7859.996.0018.41378.93196.47352.254.71-0.068.0612.30
Spartan DeltaSDE65.780.17-52.2824.0069.11715.3226.2690.932.840.615.217.89
SuncorSU12.660.567.0217.000.0068401.106.9225.6117.7829.8356.6966.60
Surge EnergySGY67.321.041.3435.0013.98763.3928.7191.905.520.029.7914.60
Tamarack ValleyTVE-0.541.253.9322.0015.012109.89-45.8923.610.800.012.054.68
Topaz EnergyTPZ-51.231.189.2619.0069.023254.78-52.70-47.615.934.5910.6411.79
TourmalineTOU18.410.385.9839.0076.1022828.17-9.1635.9832.833.4959.0088.32
Touchstone ExplorationTXP53.171.94328.3745.0079.36173.32-2.5684.610.330.000.721.37
Vermilion EnergyVET66.110.694.5040.0053.992648.2618.8390.4214.780.5619.3931.08
WhitecapWCP36.560.768.6123.0035.206219.205.3557.265.620.0110.9616.35
YangarraYGR765.741.21-13.5249.0061.81112.81592.74899.543.270.008.2411.89
Lucero EnergyPSH57.27-0.58-7.5728.0019.95415.1536.7272.700.580.000.871.11
InPlay OilIPO153.670.54-0.7029.0041.00219.58103.52191.712.110.014.907.03
Valeura EnergyVLE-26.72-0.6638404.951.000.09604.11-46.86-8.01-1.030.503.135.41

Company NameStock Chart8% DCF ValueIRR %Cash Flow YieldDebt/ CashflowUpside to NAV %EV/Cash Flow4 yr Book Growth4 yr CF Growth
Gibson EnergyGEI24.48.515.74.686.4-6.18.9
AltaGasALA-5.9-1.413.79.4-1207.3-3.915.7
TC EnergyTRP39.75.213.09.0-197.73.9-1.9
PembinaPPL36.84.810.14.2-239.9-4.5-0.8
EnbridgeENB31.64.413.95.5-347.24.39.5
KeyeraKEY38.37.912.73.997.9-2.41.1
Hydro OneH25.03.79.57.0-3410.54.48.0
AtcoACO.X91.612.824.26.31514.10.94.2
Canadian UtilitiesCU57.710.621.66.9924.62.17.3
Algonquin PowerAQN-3.0-1.111.214.7-1368.95.1-6.0
FortisFTS16.52.613.69.3-697.48.14.6
EmeraEMA10.62.717.29.4-775.823.96.5
BoralexBLX14.22.711.84.7-478.420.42.2
Capital PowerCPX23.64.818.65.2-345.4-1.60.6
Northland PowerNPI40.711.913.88.0957.217.9-17.7
InnergexINE-13.9-3.017.619.6-2735.76.0-4.9
TransaltaTA15.913.554.62.8791.8-13.512.3
Tidewater MidstreamTWM1.713.044.04.11372.3-17.74.3
Polaris InfrastructurePIF15.411.113.34.5297.5-2.1-9.6
Mullen GroupMTL27.47.711.42.0928.73.417.3
PHX Energy ServicesPHX8.26.622.4-0.5-94.515.021.4
Secure Energy Servicesses5.9-0.212.60.8-467.9-7.910.6
Enterprise GroupE1.315.432.00.8173.12.940.1
Pason SystemsPSI15.310.111.7-1.5-68.65.47.0
Computer Modelling GroupCMG4.45.66.3-0.4-5715.9-4.0-6.9
Precision DrillingPD109.611.439.51.7202.51.215.5
Badger InfrastructureBAD27.21.38.21.0-4112.1-6.44.1
Black DiamondBDI14.914.924.71.5704.18.235.1
Total Energy ServicesTOT27.144.736.8-0.21832.73.722.6
High Arctic ServicesHWO3.6495.512.0-7.01908.4-14.9-33.6
CalfracCFW12.9104.375.50.01751.3-46.3-48.1
Mattr Corp(Shawcor)SCL15.05.210.1-1.0-119.9-1.223.6
CES Energy SolutionsCEU5.714.422.4-0.724.514.210.7
TricanTCW4.110.528.4-0.6-33.53.584.4
Ensign Energy ServicesESI9.124.5110.72.22910.9-7.81.5
Western Energy ServiceWRG7.022.154.51.81501.8-60.8-56.2
Dexterra(Horizons North)HNL5.47.221.00.6-94.812.450.0
EnerflexEFX19.717.725.43.81503.9-5.436.5
North American ConstructionNOA57.817.331.12.41063.230.519.2
Source Energy ServicesSHLE25.719.149.32.0692.0-24.1-4.2
Step Energy ServicesSTEP7.123.543.70.7802.3-7.31.5
TelusT23.08.113.75.957.33.3-1.5
BCEbce48.18.618.74.575.4-4.6-0.4
A&W Income FundAW.UN23.24.15.61.3-2017.94.2-4.7
Boston Pizzabpf.UN18.38.311.32.1168.910.82.0
CN RailCNR139.14.46.12.6-2116.53.06.5
Westshore TerminalsWTE46.414.211.81.7858.51.55.4
Magna MG135.618.215.51.51066.52.0-3.3
Canadian Apartmentscar/un54.55.37.612.22813.13.48.2
Algoma CentralALC34.417.919.42.41325.14.0-3.0
Brookfield InfrastructureBIP/UN17.93.517.312.5-525.8-3.29.1
Constellation Softwaremrg/UN1490.3-1.73.02.7-5933.731.323.4
Premium BrandsPBH100.68.78.34.51512.08.34.6
NFI GroupNFI-1.5-8.1-4.4-8.7-113-22.6-16.9-50.0
Boyd Group ServicesBYD149.90.65.33.3-4418.922.22.8
ToromontTIH62.6-4.36.6-1.5-5115.118.011.1
Parkland CorpPKI55.010.222.62.9304.4-2.313.5
CCL IndustriesCCL/b69.77.37.91.0-112.713.76.6
Alimentation Coucheatd-b27.2-1.85.92.0-6417.013.921.9
CineplexCGX-8.7-0.343.09.7-2102.337.7-10.3
Canadian TireCTC/A324.918.718.02.91475.611.28.1
Stella JonesSJ69.96.42.6-1.0-1238.812.09.0
GoEasyGSY273.212.824.74.6604.028.116.4
Sleep CountryZZZ52.315.215.23.2906.642.56.6
MTY Food GroupMTY96.511.915.57.31096.5-0.113.9

[]

 

Copyright 2015-2022 NAV Information Ltd.

PDP – This shows the value of the companies existing wells, the most conservative valuation number.

Other Value – For companies with other assets that are not in the reserve report this is either the companies stated value or a discounted cash flow per share number of what those assets are worth

Proved – This is PDP + Other Value + PDNP + PUD.  PDNP is the wells that are drilled but not producing(the amount of capital required to put the wells on production was disclosed in the corporate reserves report).  PUD is the value of the high confidence locations that are remaining to drill.  In general over time the Proved value would be more likely to increase than decrease.

Proved + Probable – This is the Proved reserve value + Probable reserve value.  Probable reserve value includes a more optimistic view of the recoverable reserves and also a more optimistic view of the PDNP and PUD reserves(this may include higher reserves in the wells yet to be drilled).  One viewpoint would be that this is the best estimate of the value of the company considering all the upside.

More Detailed Information on the Data Table

8% Discount NAV

This is the theoretical value of future cash flows moved to the present using an 8% discount rate less the net debt on the balance sheet.  The model assumes a real depreciation rate for the asset and a reinvestment rate that sustains the “tangible” assets on a go forward basis.  For asset light companies such as software and royalty companies, the model uses a terminal growth rate for the cash flow per share based on historical results and reasonable growth.

IRR

Internal rate of return of those future cash flows.  The assumption is that you buy the entire company using the existing share price and debt and then pay for it using future cash generation of the company

Cash Flow Yield

The is just the inverse of the price to cash flow expressed as a percentage.  If this was a bond(which it is not) this would be a proxy for the bond yield

Debt/Cash Flow

This is the net debt of the company divided by the yearly cash flow.  The higher this number the more indebted is the company.  Each industry has a “reasonable” debt to cash flow depending on the volatility of the earnings and the longevity of the assets.  Oil producers have a reasonable limit of 3x debt/cash flow or less, Pipelines it seems 6x is not a problem given the 30-40 year life of a pipeline

20 Responses

  1. Looking forward to reading more. Great post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  2. Mp3fiesta says:

    “Thanks a lot for giving everyone an extraordinarily brilliant chance to read articles and blog posts from this blog.”

  3. try this out says:

    I just want to say I am very new to blogs and absolutely savored this page. Almost certainly I’m going to bookmark your website . You actually have amazing stories. Thank you for sharing your web site.

  4. Hi, this weekend is fastidious in support of me, as this occasion i
    am reading this great informative paragraph here at my house.

  5. I simply want to mention I am just new to blogging and site-building and truly enjoyed this blog. More than likely I’m going to bookmark your blog post . You actually come with awesome writings. Thank you for sharing your web site.

  6. internet says:

    I just want to say I’m beginner to blogs and actually liked your blog site. More than likely I’m planning to bookmark your website . You certainly have very good article content. With thanks for sharing your website page.

  7. Go Here says:

    I simply want to mention I am all new to blogs and definitely liked your blog site. Likely I’m want to bookmark your blog . You certainly come with really good writings. Appreciate it for revealing your website.

  8. “Sorry for my English.I have been reading out a few of your_ stories and i can claim nice stuff. I will surely bookmark your site.”

  9. I simply want to say I am just all new to blogging and seriously loved you’re blog site. Most likely I’m planning to bookmark your blog . You amazingly come with impressive articles and reviews. Thanks a lot for sharing your web site.

  10. George says:

    This website is really interesting. I have bookmarked it.

    Do you allow guest posting on your page ? I can write
    hi quality posts for you. Let me know.

    • admin says:

      No guest posting yet, still working through the growth and content phases of the website. Thanks for the interest though

  11. Hello, I enjoy reading all of your article. I
    wanted to write a little comment to support you.

  12. nba 2k17 says:

    I’m amazed, I must say. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s both
    equally educative and amusing, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail
    on the head. The issue is something that too few people are speaking
    intelligently about. Now i’m very happy that I came across this
    in my search for something concerning this.

  13. I’m amazed, I have to admit. Rarely do I encounter a
    blog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me
    tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is something that not enough
    men and women are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy that I came across this
    during my hunt for something concerning this.

  14. Bernardo says:

    Thanks for the good writeup. It actually was a amusement account it.

    Glance advanced to more delivered agreeable from you!
    By the way, how can we be in contact?

  15. FIFA 17 says:

    Great web websitewebsite! It looks very professional! Keep up the excellent job!

  16. KipRMellie says:

    Keep on writing, great job!

  17. TanjaLLynott says:

    It’s perfect time and energy to make some plans for the long run and it can be a chance to be at liberty.

    I have got read this post and if I could I would like to suggest you
    few fascinating issues or advice. Perhaps you can write subsequent articles concerning this informative
    article. I desire to read more issues about it!

  18. Normally I do not learn article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very great post.